Buy. Appraise. Consign.
We currently buy the following Trading Card Games in Bulk at a rate of $2.50/1,000 cards:
Magic the Gathering
Dragon Ball Super Masters
Lorcana
Star Wars Unlimited
Digimon
UniVersus
We currently buy the following Trading Card Games in Bulk at a rate of $5/1,000 cards:
One Piece
Pokemon
We currently buy cards valued above $3 for the following games at variable rates based upon fair market value:
One Piece
Magic the Gathering
Pokemon
Dragon Ball Super Masters
Dragon Ball Super Fusion World
Digimon
Lorcana
One Piece
Star Wars Unlimited
UniVersus
NOTE: AS OF AUGUST 1, 2024 THERE IS A $500 MINIMUM ESTIMATED TOTAL (100% Market) VALUE FOR YOUR COLLECTION TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A CASH (RATHER THAN CREDIT) PAYOUT. ALL TRADES IN EXCESS OF $250 REQUIRE AN APPOINTMENT.
Trading for store credit will ALWAYS get you better value than trading for cash. We generally offer cash at 50% or better and credit at 60% or better but pricing varies based on a multitude of factors. We encourage you to ask questions when we make our offer if the number is not what you expect. Cards valued between $1 and $3 are usually purchased at a reduced rate, and cards under $1 are almost always priced as bulk.
If you want to ship us a trade in, please build your collection on TCGPlayer and email us your list for a tentative offer. Once we have received your items and verified your list is accurate, we will send you payment via check or EFT.
OTHER SERVICES
Appraisal
Whether you found a shoebox full of you-don’t-know-what at a yard sale or you’ve been holding onto a miscut Worldwake Jayce for the better part of a decade, we’ll find the best possible comps so you know exactly what you have and exactly how much to ask for it. This service begins at $30/hour, a fee which is waived if you opt to use our services to sell your items when we are finished.
Consignment
This is typically reserved for situations where you are looking to sell cards that are worth a large sum of money and/or are especially unique. We will let you know if this is an appropriate option for your trade in.
sorting Services
We offer several services to help organize your collection. All rates are priced per 1,000 cards.
Sift - $12
We sift your collection for you! You will be returned your bulk in one pile and all of your cards over the value threshold of your choice when we are finished. (Lorcana, Pokemon, and Magic the Gathering ONLY)
Alphabetize - $20
We alphabetize your collection and return it to you cleanly sorted. (Lorcana, One Piece, Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, and UniVersus ONLY)
Sort by Set + Alphabetize - $30
We will not only alphabetize your cards, but we will sort them in chronological or alphabetical set order for you! (Lorcana, One Piece, Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, and UniVersus ONLY)
Sort by Set + Alphebetize & Sift - $40
We will alphabetize your entire collection and return it to you cleanly sorted, and also sift and catalog all cards over a value threshold of your choosing! (Lorcana, Pokemon, and Magic the Gathering ONLY)
Other Games/Sorting Methods - Contact us
If you are not local to us or you have questions, give us a call or email us.
other notes:
We find that buy lists often result in outdated prices, and can set unreasonable expectations that we are actively seeking certain cards and do not want others. For those reasons, we do not have one.
Similarly, since we are not specifically seeking any card, we ask that you know what you are interested in selling BEFORE you bring your cards into the store. We will not cherry-pick from binders, boxes, or a giant pile.
We strongly encourage you to do your own research, unless you are hiring us to appraise your collection, so you have an idea of whether you feel our offer is reasonable.
If you feel our offer is unreasonable, please say so BEFORE we have completed our transaction. You won’t hurt our feelings.
If, at any point in the process you have questions, please ask them.
Trade ins should be submitted in boxes, without sleeves, and with a reasonable effort to separate value over $1 from true bulk.
In cases where thousands of cards are submitted in binders or sleeves, and where no attempt has been made to delineate between bulk and non-bulk, we deduct 10% from our offer to cover the additional labor.
If you have a very large quantity of bulk, we may be willing to come pick it up within a 5 hour driving radius (CT, MA, NH, NY, NJ, PA).
Trade-Ins: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How does your trade-in process work?
We make trading in your cards easy! Bring in your cards during store hours, and we’ll evaluate them based on condition, demand, and market value. We offer store credit (which gets you the best value) or cash (at a lower rate).
If you have a large collection or rare cards that need extra attention, we recommend scheduling an appointment so we can give your cards the time they deserve.
What kinds of cards do you accept?
We accept singles, bulk, and sealed product for the following games:
Pokémon TCG
Magic: The Gathering
Dragon Ball Super Card Game Masters
One Piece Card Game
Disney Lorcana
Digimon Card Game
UniVersus
Star Wars Unlimited
If you’re unsure whether we’ll take a specific card or product, feel free to ask!
Do you accept bulk cards?
Yes! We take bulk for certain games. Our rates vary based on the game, rarity, and demand. Bulk must be sorted by rarity (and set if possible) and in near-mint condition—no damaged, bent, or heavily played cards.
What’s the difference between store credit and cash offers?
We always offer more value in store credit than in cash. Store credit can be used on anything in the shop, including sealed products, singles, accessories, and event entries.
Cash offers are lower because of market resale factors, but they’re a great option if you’re looking for immediate payout.
How long does it take for you to appraise my cards?
Small trade-ins can often be evaluated on the spot, but larger collections may take more time. If you have a sizable trade-in (over 1,000 cards or high-value singles), we strongly recommend scheduling an appointment.
Do you charge for appraisals?
For general trade-ins, there’s no fee. However, if you need a formal appraisal for insurance or collection valuation, we charge $30 per hour for this service.
Do I need to prepare my cards before bringing them in?
Yes, please! To speed up the process and ensure the best rates, follow these steps:
✔️ Sort bulk by rarity (and set if possible)
✔️ Remove cards from binders, sleeves, and toploaders (unless they are high-value cards)
✔️ Bring them in a box or deck box for easy handling
Do you buy sealed products or accessories?
We may accept sealed booster boxes, packs, and decks for trade-in, depending on demand and condition. We generally do not buy used accessories (binders, deck boxes, playmats), but exceptions may be made for high-demand items.
How do I schedule a trade-in appointment?
You can call, email, or message us on Discord to set up a time. Walk-ins are welcome, but for large collections or high-value singles, an appointment ensures we can give your cards the proper attention.
Can I trade in cards towards event entries?
Absolutely! Store credit from trade-ins can be used to cover entry fees for our events, tournaments, and other store purchases.
What if I have rare or graded cards?
We evaluate rare and graded cards individually, considering factors like condition, set, and demand. If you have high-value cards, we recommend bringing any authentication paperwork or grading info with you.
Can I put my cards on consignment instead of selling them outright?
Yes! If you prefer, we can help you sell your high-value cards through consignment. This means we list and sell them for you, and once they sell, you get a percentage of the sale. Ask us for details on our consignment rates and process.